- Well for one I am never sure if one of my friends is posting something from their own blog, or some other place I am interested in, or they are posting about something completely unrelated/unintresting. I know, I know the message is supposed say something about the url, but it doesn't always, and it certainly doesn't let me eliminate sites I don't like (say I don't like Mashable, not true of course, I can't know that one of my friends just posted a Mashable link).
- It is huge security problem. The links are anonymous, so we have no idea where they go. As a web professional I can identify some weird links just from there look, but perhaps more importantly I don't think many of the automatic url scanners in the browsers (for phishing, etc.) actually resolve the url to its source, and therefore don't identify malware sites which have been shortened.
The other half of this issue is for the Twitter search, try doing a search for http://www.techcrunch.com on Twitter's search engine. You'll find many fewer results than there really are... that is unless you start getting the shortened versions of the Techcrunch url. Before you say, well okay I'll get the tinyurl and bit.ly url and a few others and be done with it (and with the explosion of shortened url services, good luck with finding the best shortened urls to use)... Twitter search has a 140 character limit, so good luck doing more than 2 shortened urls. Additionally good luck doing a wildcard search for http://www.techcrunch.com/* to get all techcrunch posts urls as well, this is impossible with these anonymized urls that hide the actual url structure.
So there is my rant, and my evidence, let me know what you think either in the comments or @jostheim on twitter, but for goodness sake don't include a shortened url!
Every time I see a shortened URL I wonder what will happen when that url shortener goes out of business. Those urls will be lost completely, I'm thinking.
ReplyDeleteAlso, most of the shortener companies don't seem to have a business model (or do they?). The one exception is adjix, which slaps an ad bar across the top. Twitter resolving urls would pretty much kill their business..
I read that the inventor of tinyurl is making 1M dollars a month... I have no idea how. My guess, is that they sell tracking services.
ReplyDeleteGoing out of business, I agree totally. Another problem I have seen is that the shorteners **SEEM** to reuse hashes sometimes, so a shortened url only goes to the right place for a period of time.
Sigh, just wish twitter did as well as Friendfeed on this stuff.